Tom Cooper, Portsmouth Cathedral, November 19
At the risk of belabouring a point, I don't know why Bach is widely regarded as the greatest composer and yet we are served relatively little of his music at lunchtime recitals. I've been told it's too difficult, I realize that a good part of his greatness lies in choral music and that one can't live on champagne alone, although I wouldn't mind trying. But thanks to Tom Cooper for bringing the Liszt transcription of the Prelude and Fugue, BWV 543.
The Prelude was brooding but also chimed; the Fugue more complex with, as Tom explained in the first of his useful introductions, three lines integrated in a metaphor to represent the Holy Trinity. Open and optimistic, the left hand applied more power and resonance as it progressed.
In some contrast, Robert Schumann's Romance, op. 28, no. 2, was a love song to Clara of some doubt and restraint and, yes, his The prophet bird did indeed anticipate Debussy, somewhat ahead of its time, disembodied and inconclusive in a 'modern' way.
The programme was intended as Autumnal and while I don't find Brahms always 'gloomy', the Andante moderato of the op. 117 Three Intermezzi was taken at what might have passed as adagio with sepulchral implications. The second was increasingly introspective and in the third interpretation of Andante the shadowy melody emerged from its mist. It has prompted me to check on the literal meaning of the word and I've found 'at walking pace'. It would be interesting to discuss it with Brahms and Tom. Perhaps I walk faster than them.
But by that time the sun had come out outside as compensation for those who had arrived in chilly rain and we could reflect on a thoughtful, insightful performance rewarded by a good-sized audience that would have gone away rewarded in return, feeling the wiser for it.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: only a member of this blog may post a comment.